Monday, March 2, 2009

Review of Reading 16: Ill Winds: The Chemical Plant Next Door



A Review of Ill Winds: The Chemical Plant Next Door

by Becky Bradway
Published in E: The Environmental Magazine, September/October 2002

The Town:
Becky Bradway writes about her life from the time she was 8 years old until the time she was 10 years old and moving back to the small town of Buffalo, Illinois, with her mother and father.
Buffalo, was right down the road from Borden Chemical. She writes about how she loved that town nearly as much as her mother hated it. Her mother hated it so much that she never went outside except to get in her car and drive away. Looking at a town through a childs eye is different than an adults eye as Ms. Bradway explains how she didn’t know or care about unemployment and pollution and the other negative things that get people down. Was a very depressed area.

Chemicals Industry:
Becky Bradway did a bunch of research about the chemical industry and came up with the fact that
Pesticides, herbicides, industrial chemicals, even cow shit: She learned it all. Factories, coal tar, farms, sewage: put them all together, and things die. She keeps referring to the floating fish, which were dying in the river. All these elements were present in central Illinois.

Borden:
Statistics:
Wholly Owned Subsidiary of Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co.
Incorporated: 1899 as Borden Condensed Milk Company
Employees: 20,000
Sales: $5.77 billion (1996)
SICs: 2034 Dried & Dehydrated Fruits, Vegetables & Soup Mixes; 2096 Potato Chips, Corn Chips & Similar Snacks; 2098 Macaroni, Spaghetti, Vermicelli & Noodles; 2099 Food Preparations, Not Elsewhere Classified;
2821 Plastics Materials, Nonvulcanizable Elastomers & Synthetic Resins; 2891 Adhesives & Sealants; 3089 Plastic Products, Not Elsewhere Classified

Borden, Inc. built this plant in 1962, in
Illiopolis, Ill and produced Elmer’s Glue, and a competitor to Saran Wrap called Resinite and in 1987 it began making polyvinyl chloride (PVC) when it came under new ownership as Borden Chemicals and Plastics Limited Partnership (BCP). Later on, the company filed chapter 11 bankruptcy and was purchased by Formosa Plastics Corporation from Taiwan, in 2002.

Borden's specialties were initially resins, formaldehyde, then later polyvinyl chloride (PVC). These chemicals can cause high rates of cancer amongst workers along with the workers these chemicals, through various channels, make their way into the surrounding environment. In this particular area the nearby Sangamon River, drinking water, and landfills are getting polluted. The sad thing is these companies are able to obtain waivers and exemptions that allow them to bypass Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) laws. But in this area with so many fams and other companies it it hard to just blame Borden. Here are some scary numbers that don't reflect very well for Borden.

*
They were caught shipping 2,500 drums of highly toxic mercury waste to South Africa. The stockpiled drums leaked contaminants -- a disaster that led to both criminal and civil investigations in South Africa.

*
The U.S. Justice Department filed a lawsuit accusing the company of illegal hazardous waste storage, contaminating groundwater, burning waste without a permit and neglecting to report chemical releases into the air.

*
The plant can legally dump 800,000 gallons of wastewater into the stream every day. Just two miles down, this water reaches the Sangamon River. Because the area around the stream is wooded, locals hunt and fish there.

*
Not counting accidents, the plant routinely releases 65,000 pounds of vinyl chloride and 40,000 pounds of vinyl acetate into the Central Illinois air every year.

*
Not only do the pollutants cause cancer, vinyl chloride is suspected of disrupting female hormones, which makes, women and girls especially -- vulnerable to all kinds of illnesses.

I wish I could live there!!!

Blue-Collar Risks:
This whole area of Ill. is not really too safe.

*
Becky Bradway's family had thought their choices made them safe. We lived in the country by the river, away from the city and its violence. We never traveled, never took a plane or train or bus, never drove farther than “town.” Yet her parents killer was right there in the air an in the water.

* She tells a story of
her uncle Wade who had talked about men who worked in a nearby factory. Each had died or was dying from a rare cancer. They’d been forced to climb into tanks to clean out mystery chemical crap. Anyone who said no was fired. “They swelled up big as blimps before they kicked off,” Wade said. “Pathetic bastards.”

* She also tells of a construction worker who thinks that since he's not working in the mill that he won't get sick. Only thing is that these workers are still breathing the air and drinking the water. On top of that there body's are all physically worn out from manual labor by the time they are 40 years old.


What's the plant doing today? Check out the following link.
Illiopolis: Center of disaster and environmental hazard

My Thoughts,
I feel bad for anybody that has lived in a city like this and didn't or couldn't do anything about it. I come from a city that had three big mills in town and without those mills the town would be dead. I hope that, because I don't know, our city wasn't contaminated like this. Most of the time people in cities like this think that they are safe until it is to late.

21 comments:

  1. Derek,
    It is crazy to think that the smaller towns aren't as safe as we thought. Like I said on Ben's blog, it's hard not to assume a correlation between the factories pollution and cancer when so many people around there have been affected by it. I would move too if I was in their situation. But then again, you can't really move away from all pollution. Great Post, Derek!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Derek,

    Good summary, you got all the facts and stories straight! I also have empathy for the "small-town" people who are stuck in these types of environments, atleast until they are old enough to move or drive. It's pretty sick that the plant was legally able to dump 800,000 gallons of waste into the streams...and you wonder why the public is getting sick. I think the gov't definitely needs to look into this, and help make people aware of polluted air that could be affecting their health!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I feel so bad for those people in that city too! How can the plant be able to dump so much pollution into the streams? You would think that our government would regulate this! Great job on your post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey Derek,
    I cannot believe the way the conditions in these small towns have undergone. If there's 800,000 gallons of waste going into local water supplies, people are going to be living with the consequences for a long time. They need to make some adjustments and change the way things are going!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think we put too much trust in big corporations to be regulate their practices to make sure that they are being environmentally-friendly towards the community. Too bad more people don't have the confidence or resources to take action for their own health.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Derek!
    This was a good review! Yes, surprisingly cow shit was even a harmful factor. How scary! Thanks for doing further research and getting statistics on the Borden company! That is so interesting. It looks like the billions of dollars really shows for companies with power!
    I hope it's not too late either!!
    Thanks Derek!

    Kathy

    ReplyDelete
  7. Derek
    I really like that you had soo many statistics on Borden. That was really cool!! I feel really bad for the people living in the surrounding communities..something needs to be done!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Derek-

    Great review!! It was packed with statistics and layed out really well. It was easy to follow and I like how you would throw your own personal comments in there. I like the point u made in your final thoughts, without the plants/mills the town would be "dead", but at the same time those mills and plants are killing aspects of the environment within these towns. Crazy how everything is a cycle.

    ReplyDelete
  9. GREAT review! You do an excellent job in all of yours, going in to depth and being very throughout. I think it's horrible that there are companies like that, and that they're really don't take the blame for it or any responsibilities. Nothing will change if the companies aren't recognizing their wrong doings...

    ReplyDelete
  10. Derek

    It's crazy to read something like this after reading all of the other readings and having this one be so sad! It seems like you did a lot of extra research on the topic, and it was really interesting to see all of the facts and click on the links. I feel bad for people who think that they are stuck in small towns. I'd like to think or hope at least that there are other opportunities that could come to them. Great review as always!!

    Heather

    ReplyDelete
  11. Good review, Derek! I really liked the link you added to the Illiopolis news article - what a mess. I agree that unfortunately people who live in such situations don't realize it until it's too late. Also, great job going in depth with the Borden statistics, although I find it a little unnerving that they used to make food products. Hopefully those standards were a little stricter!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hey Derek,
    It is sad to know how people are affected by polution. I never really thought about its effects until I read this article. It also sad to know that the gov doesn't do much abotu it. I was really shocked to find that "Not counting accidents, the plant routinely releases 65,000 pounds of vinyl chloride and 40,000 pounds of vinyl acetate into the Central Illinois air every year". It's a scary thought!!
    Good job!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Derek- I loved the comment halfway through where you sarcastically stated in bold, "I'd love to live there!". Great way to jazz this review up with some personality.
    I also feel bad for everyone in those towns who have to experience either themselves or a loved one deal with the effects of factory pollution/contamination. One fact that struck me and I think will worry me for a long time is that the chemicals tend to interact with a woman's hormones causing an array of diseases/illnesses for females. That is so scary to me. I have three sisters...I hope they don't ever settle in a town where they are at risk of abnormal cancers/disease due to chemical dumping.
    You really opened my eyes when you made the comment, "a child doesn't see the town or the world the way an adult does". I know you are much older than I am, but I feel like this class is sort of the gateway to the adult thinking. I am learning to look past the way the houses look on the road, or the number of church steps and look more at how many people are happily employed and who is affected by what constructs of the town. Very interesting to watch all of our mindsets and way of thinking change! --S

    ReplyDelete
  14. Good review! yeah that town sounds just disgusting, I wouldn't want to live there. I liked the way you broke everything down into smaller easy to read portions. The stats on the company were a very nice touch.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Very well organized review Derek! I like that you put that stats in about Borden. I eat a lot of pasta and it isn't a delightful sight to see that Borden produces quite a bit of supplies to make different pasta dishes. It's going to make me research a little bit about what pasta noodles I should purchase.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Derek, it was really intersting to hear that you grew up in a town with three big mills and that your town needed those mills to survive. I have no idea what that is like, it sounds really scary to think that the place you grew up, wasn't necessarily as safe as you thought. I really enjoyed this reading because I got to hear about what it is like to live in a rural town. I now know that it contains some dangers that none of us really thought were possible. Great review!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Derek~I love your post and giving it a personal note made it even better to read! I also liked on how you had things split up too, it made it easier to read and follow!! Awesome work once again!! Keep it UP!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Derek- Great job this week you always do such good work...impressive! The plant can legally dump 800,000 gallons of waste water into the stream every day. It this really true... i just don't even understand how this is possible! It is really upsetting! Then think about eating fish out of the river... no wonder people are getting diseases! It is really upsetting, but I still keep asking myself after reading all of these posting...What can we do, I feel so helpless...Great job this week Derek you keep setting the bar high! :)

    ReplyDelete
  19. Derek,

    It is true that without these big plants the town would be less populated. They do bring it lots of employment oppurtunity. If only the chemical plants and other environmentally harmful corporations could put their money into research for better cleaner production of their products. We would all benifit from this better control of harmful substances. This is a neccessity and I hope the governement will step in to help facilitate this change and get the research and development to more safley produce their product. The post you have made gives me a lot of statistical data I can use to formulate a complaint. It is good that we have this data so we as the American public can issue a formal complaint to the governement to try and get them to change.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I actually liked the way this reading was written. It was an actual story that made it easy to follow. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Why are we still allowed to use this stuff? that seems like a lot of stuff to be just dumping into the river.

    ReplyDelete

Green Comments Here